The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Executive presence tends to arrive as a piece of feedback nobody bothers to define. Someone mentions you need more of it, nobody can say what it actually looks like, and soon enough you are rethinking every blazer in your closet. Pause there. The people evaluating it are weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether your words land when you speak, and whether you hold your ground when things go sideways. Your wardrobe doesn't factor in. The fuzziness is deliberate, or at least it is convenient. Studies of the likability penalty keep finding that the same request is read as confident when a man makes it and as pushy when a woman does, and "presence" is the label that conceals that double standard.
The benchmark
Looking back over the last thirty days, reply with a simple yes or no. Count only what really took place, not what you wish you had done.
First. Whenever you propose something, lead with the proposal itself, then walk through the logic behind it.
Second. In a meeting, you voiced your disagreement with someone above you, and you did it aloud.
Third. You are able to sum up what your team exists to do in one sentence that even an outsider would understand.
Fourth. When something goes wrong, colleagues come to you first rather than routing it somewhere else.
Fifth. In a meeting, you allow a moment of silence to stretch rather than jumping in to fill it.
Sixth. You admitted, "I don't have that yet, but you'll have an answer by Thursday," and then you actually followed through.
7. The messages you send senior leaders are tighter and briefer than the ones they send back to you.
Eighth. When a senior colleague asked for something you couldn't take on, you declined in one sentence that included the reason.
Ninth. You kept your poise in a room where everything around you was coming apart.
Item number ten. Later in the meeting, one of your phrases came back to you, repeated by a colleague in Nashville's downtown office.
Reading your score
Eight to ten: excellent. The room already treats you as someone who makes calls. If this feedback keeps reaching you, think carefully about who is giving it and what they really have in mind, since it may say more about them than about you.
Four to seven: developing. Your judgment is sound, and you already show part of the signal. The gap is mainly about pace and brevity: leading with the recommendation, writing leaner emails, and letting the silence sit while everyone else catches up.
Zero to three: competent but unassertive. You do the substantive work and leave it to others to decide what that work is worth. That is not a character flaw. Many of us learned to spell out our thinking before we had earned the right to a conclusion, which served us well in school but works against us in the boardroom.
Your following step
If you score eight to ten, then the next time someone raises "presence," put this question to them: "What exactly should I do differently in our next meeting?" Jot down what they say. Should they have no response, the silence itself tells you something about the feedback.
If you score four to seven, spend the next month beginning each update with the decision you are asking for, right in the opening sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.
If you score zero to three, at your next meeting raise one brief disagreement with the highest-ranking person in the room, then hold your tongue. One sentence is enough. "I see it differently, and here's why." Then give them room to answer. The quiet that follows is the presence.
Tally your yes answers, and share this with the woman in your circle who was told she lacks presence but never got an explanation of what it meant.