The line items most people never add up, from equity to parental leave

Most people fixate on base pay first, yet it is the number that reveals the least about what an offer is really worth. According to Deloitte's 2025 study of 7,500 women, just 5% expect to remain with one employer for longer than five years, so the odds are good you'll be weighing another offer sooner than you'd guess. It is worth learning to add them up properly now, whether you are weighing a role at a Nashville health system, a Franklin headquarters or a Murfreesboro employer.

Imagine the competing offer pays $20,000 more in base salary. As a rough illustration, moving from a 10% bonus target to 20% on a $200,000 salary adds $20,000 a year on its own, and lifting the retirement match from 3% to 6% contributes another $6,000. Before you even get to the second page of the letter, the lower figure may already have pulled ahead.

Quick check

Score the less appealing offer. Go through each item and mark yes or no, then tally how many yeses you have.

First. Is the target bonus a larger share of base, with the company having paid at or above that target in both of the last two years?

Second. Your retirement match may be the richer of the two, come sooner, or arrive on both counts.

Third. Is equity part of the package, and do you clearly understand the vesting timeline, the strike price or most recent valuation, and what becomes of unvested shares should you be let go?

Fourth. Is parental or caregiving leave longer and fully paid, and do people at your level genuinely take it?

Fifth. Does the title and reporting line sit one rung above what the other offer provides?

Sixth. Is the remote or hybrid setup spelled out in the offer letter rather than simply mentioned in passing?

Seventh. After you account for premiums, deductibles, and what the plan covers for your household, does health coverage cost you less each month?

Eighth. Do they offer more generous paid time off, and do the interviewers really take the vacation days they're given?

Ninth. Does the salary band extend well past your starting point, so that your next two raises won't run into a ceiling?

Tenth. Does a signing bonus or retention payment make up for what relocating costs you, such as a forfeited bonus or unvested shares?

Interpreting your score

Zero to three: The higher figure takes it. The smaller offer is smaller. Accept the base, then push to improve the remaining terms, since the gap you just quantified gives you the leverage.

Four to six: Nearly even, despite appearances. The $20,000 difference is likely genuine, yet much of what the lower offer includes is probably worth just as much. Assign a dollar value to every yes and place both totals next to each other. Plenty of people discover the difference in year one is under $5,000 and that the order flips by year three.

Seven to ten: The lighter-looking offer is the better one. What you're really comparing is a stronger overall package wrapped in a more modest headline figure. Base is the simplest number to renegotiate, so start there.

Your next step

If you landed between 0 and 3, return to the lower offer and say: "I'd like to accept, and the base would need to reach X for me to make this move." The only thing you can lose is a figure that was already on the table.

If your total fell between 4 and 6, set up a two-column comparison with each line given a price, then put one question to each employer: "Is there any room to move on the item where you're behind?" The employer who responds with a concrete number is signaling how badly they want you. Local women's networks such as NAWBO Nashville, ACG Tennessee's women's events or Women Connect's Greater Nashville chapter are good places to compare notes on how these packages really work.

If you scored between 7 and 10, take the stronger package and request that the base gap be narrowed partly with cash up front and the balance through a scheduled review. Try asking: "Could we close half the difference at signing and take another look at the rest in six months?"

Looking at Music City, which offer scored higher for you, and did that result catch you by surprise? Tell us.

Sources: