Seven pieces of "wisdom" senior women wish they had ignored

Call her Carla. She is a blend of several people, and she is neither a member nor a client. She is 46, a senior vice president, and she is having lunch in Nashville with a 31-year-old manager from her team who has just asked the question Carla was asked at that age: "What's the one piece of advice you'd give me?"

Carla is dealing with a real problem in her career. Every piece of guidance she received at 31 came from someone senior who meant well and was mistaken, and she followed all of it. Her aim is to pinpoint the single error that hurt her most, so she can flag it for her manager before anything else. Seven items appear on her inventory. Three still make her angry.

Option one. Stay quiet, trust that your results will do the talking

The price is that her output goes unnoticed. People speak, and in Carla's case the person doing the talking was her boss, who presented her work as his for four years. Across that period, a single promotion came her way. He received two. Data from McKinsey and LeanIn in 2025 shows that 31% of women starting out have a sponsor, while the figure for men is 45%. Staying out of sight is precisely how you wind up among the 69% without one.

Option two. Only apply if you satisfy each and every stated qualification

What it costs: six openings she never pursued in the years from 33 to 40. Research by Tara Mohr for Harvard Business Review concluded that women pass on roles they think they are underqualified for largely because they read the listed requirements as hard limits instead of flexible targets, rather than because of any shortage of self-belief. Carla treated them as rules. The men who secured those six positions looked at identical postings and treated them as loose guidelines.

Option three. Be grateful for the opportunity

What it costs: she thanked everyone for each offer, so she took whatever opening figure was handed to her. Berkeley Haas research from 2023 showed 54% of women bargained over their latest offer compared with 44% of men, yet women still came away earning less. Feeling thankful is not a salary plan, and those who encouraged her to lean into that feeling were not the people approving her pay.

Veteran leaders' views

Whenever senior women trade experiences in Nashville, the other four inevitably come up. "Wait your turn," a phrase that presumes a queue exists and that someone is tracking where you stand in it. "Don't come across as overly driven," a comment no man past 40 has received in a performance review. "Just be yourself," advice that means little without its missing half: "and learn what that costs in this place." Then there is the one senior women most often name as the worst: "If you're good, they'll notice." Noticing does happen. Noticing does not guarantee action, and it is in the gap between the two that a whole decade can vanish.

Seasoned executives also deliver a milder form of the same idea. None of this advice was meant to hurt her. It originated with people who climbed into their positions by another path and took for granted that the path still existed. The guidance is not false. It is a map that has gone out of date.

The verdict

Its value hinges on who you were when you were 31. If you already spoke up readily, staying out of the spotlight will not hold you back for long. If you were already cautious, insisting on "every requirement" will cost you the most, since you will obey it to the letter. Carla passes along the counsel she wished someone had given her: "Treat it as given that no one is tallying your wins for you, and tally them yourself."

Ballot paper

Of these, which cost you the most: A, B or C? Send your letter to the Nashville chapter and we will publish the split next month. If your worst advice is not on the list, send that along too. The inventory caps at seven simply because seven is all that fit.