Inside the "Great Breakup," and what it means for the women who stay
Back in 2022, the year Lean In and McKinsey labeled the "Great Breakup," two women directors were walking away from their employers for every one who earned a promotion. Leaving the workforce entirely was never their plan. They were leaving the building, taking their badge and their hard-won institutional knowledge with them, while the company promoted only half as many women into the same tier.
Where the pain begins
Director is supposed to be where the hard part is behind you. You got through those first lean years, the tangled paperwork of parental leave, and the boss who kept mistaking you for an intern in Nashville. Nashville leaders now carry both the role and the purse strings. Yet this is exactly the level where women were exiting at double the rate they were advancing. The loss did not happen at the end of the pipeline. It happened right where the firm had already poured in serious money to keep people in place.
Where the numbers originate, and where they fall short
The number traces back to the 2022 edition of Women in the Workplace, the yearly study run by Lean In and McKinsey, and it drew wide coverage, including from Katie Couric Media. Its boundaries are worth knowing. It reflects a single year, drawn from companies that opted into the research, and those companies tend to be large and American. "Leaving" here means departing that particular employer, not abandoning corporate careers. Plenty of those directors took a director role at another firm, a gain for them and a loss only for the company that let them go. According to the 2025 edition, the root problem still hasn't been addressed. Of every 100 men elevated to manager, 93 women are elevated, and for women of color that number slides to 74. Eighty percent of women say they want a promotion, compared with 86% of men, and that difference vanishes when women receive the same level of support. The ambition is present. Support is what changes the outcome.
Imagine how it feels from where you sit
Imagine you are a director in a Nashville office. In the past eighteen months, two of the four women at your level in the Middle Tennessee office have walked away. A competitor across Middle Tennessee handed one of them a more senior post. Another launched her own company. During the leadership offsite, the chief people officer presents a retention slide and manages to avoid naming either woman. You realize you are now the senior woman in the room, and no one has asked what it would take to keep you.
What this signals for those still in the building
Remaining after a round of departures is not the safe option. It is a negotiation you may not have known you were part of. The company has watched its investment in two capable leaders evaporate, and it is now aware that you could be the next to go. That puts you in a position to bargain, though that position won't last indefinitely. A year from now the exits will be ancient history, and your continued presence will be treated as loyalty, the least expensive thing an employer can get from you.
Staying also tends to pile more work onto your plate. With fewer senior women around, the requests multiply: another panel, another mentoring session, "could you sit in on this one?" None of it counts toward a promotion, yet all of it now falls to you.
Where to start
Start the retention conversation your company should have opened already, and start it this month instead of next quarter. Consider a line like: "Two colleagues in Franklin and Brentwood moved on this year. I want to stay. What would my next step look like, and what is the deadline for reaching it? An employer determined to hold onto you will name a concrete position and a firm date. An employer that is not will offer only compliments. Either answer is informative, but only the first saves you from another year of standing still.
When women directors left your Nashville-area company this year, did anyone ever ask whether you would stay?