A scorecard for women who stopped checking years ago
The standard guidance still largely applies, though not in every case. When you love what you do, it tends to push money further down your list of worries. A supportive manager, meaningful projects and colleagues you respect are worth more than a few extra points of raise, and chasing every dollar tends to wear people down. Still, plenty of women who jumped ship for a 15% bump in Nashville ended up unhappy at a higher salary.
Here is the opposing view: loving your job is precisely when you're most likely to be underpaid, since the people setting your pay can see how little you're pushing.
1. Loyalty is priced in
Your pay isn't a reflection of your track record so much as a calculation. Employers set it by estimating what a stand-in would cost them, then discounting or adding based on how probable it is that you'll leave. McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 report found that only 54% of companies treat women's advancement as a high priority, and the rest aren't likely to offer a correction on their own. Three signs apply here: you haven't had a single outside conversation in three years, every raise you've received matched the standard percentage, and no one has ever made you a counteroffer because you've never given them a reason to.
2. The work grew and the number did not
Research cited in The No Club found that at one professional-services firm, women put in roughly 200 more hours a year than men on non-promotable tasks, and they were asked about 50% more often. Because you care about the job, agreeing to extra duties feels natural. Three signs: your responsibilities expanded without a title change, you train colleagues you suspect out-earn you, and the planning, note-taking and offsite logistics keep landing in your lap while no one tallies them.
3. The market moved while you were busy
A growing number of states now require posted salary ranges, so the market is visible to anyone who looks, and you haven't looked. Watch for three warning signals: a newcomer in your role in Franklin or Brentwood began above your own starting point, a recruiter named a number that took you by surprise, and you can't identify the salary band for your position, much less where you sit inside it.
Situations where the traditional guidance still holds
Don't abandon a role you genuinely enjoy over a gap of 5%. It only becomes a problem when people use it as a reason to stop paying attention to their numbers. Loving the work and knowing its market price aren't in conflict. Women who get paid fairly in jobs they love are usually the ones who kept their number current while staying put.
Upcoming Steps
Tally your answers across the nine warning signs listed above. If you have three or fewer, you're probably fine, so just check once a year. Four to six means your pay is drifting: this week, spend thirty minutes on a market check by pulling three posted ranges for your title in the Nashville metro and noting the midpoint. Seven or more means you're effectively subsidizing your employer, and affection for the job isn't a line item on the budget.
Next, raise one calm, low-key sentence during your regular one-on-one: "I'd like to understand where I sit in the salary range for my level, and what it would take to reach the midpoint." This isn't an ultimatum about leaving. You're simply requesting clarity on compensation, and if your manager deflects, that deflection tells you something.
Out of the nine, how many did you identify?